Subject: They're a bit... well, it's rather a shotgun approach.
Author:
Posted on: 2013-09-06 16:43:00 UTC

Basically, as explained by Liliac in OFUDisc:

"[Without Elves] the whole of fiction would fall apart," she said. "We know – we've checked. There's a universe where the most popular subject for fanfic is, I kid you not, The Sound of Music – which has been remade six times. That's what happens without elves – and it still could. [...] Cruelty to elves is lessening people's respect for the fantastic. It doesn't matter if it's an original character torturing Legolas or the PPC killing a Mary-Sue – it turns the immortal into a joke. And if we let that happen, the human imagination will die."

It seems that they aren't defending any particular type of elf - more the notion of 'elf' in the human consciousness. So they'll defend House Elves (because they're called elves), and Santa's Elfs (because they're called elves), and anything which is referred to as an elf. They're a bit fundamentalist about the whole thing.

And yes, the places where this idea falls apart are part of the storyline of The Ispace Wars. I will probably address the issue of whether a character can be 'more elven' than another, too.

hS

Reply Return to messages