Subject: New Mission!
Author:
Posted on: 2015-01-08 21:45:00 UTC
Here it is, my old badfic ripped apart for all to see.
-
New Mission! by
on 2015-01-08 21:45:00 UTC
-
Good work. by
on 2015-01-10 19:53:00 UTC
Reply
And we see yet another Boarder overcome the shackles of an old shame. Good work, Rina!
However, there are a few things amiss with the mission:
1) In this segment, it takes a while to figure out who said what in the middle paragraph:
"Ooh, I wanna be in Hufflepuff!" Randa said. Rina looked at her.
"...said nobody in the history of forever," she said slowly. Randa kicked at her. "Ow! Randa, you know I didn't mean that!" Rina rubbed her shin. "I like Hufflepuffs too, come on!"
"Hufflepuff," Randa said firmly.
I eventually figured out that all of the quotes in the middle paragraph are Rina's lines, but the paragraphing threw me off. (You have Rina react at the end of the first paragraph, then start a new paragraph with a quote, so I expected a change in speaker back to Randa. The "she" in the paragraph muddied the water even more. Only the context of the rest of the paragraph cleared everything up.) Please allow me suggest a fix:
"Ooh, I wanna be in Hufflepuff!" Randa said.
Rina looked at her. "...said nobody in the history of forever," she said slowly.
Randa kicked at her.
"Ow! Randa, you know I didn't mean that!" Rina rubbed her shin. "I like Hufflepuffs too, come on!"
"Hufflepuff," Randa said firmly.
This way, it's a lot clearer who said what.
2)
A horrible smell hit them just then; Rina peered out into the corridor. "Here comes Peter," she said, one hand pressed over her nose, "and he's covered in Stinksap." ...
Randa couldn't keep the grin off her face. "So, what have we learned here about proof reading?"
Rina stuck her tongue out.
Unless the Stinksap is something that a Harry Potter fan should know about, I'm guessing that it's the result of a spelling error in the Words. Please tell me what the context is.
Either way, not too shabby a mission. -
Duly noted about the formatting. by
on 2015-01-10 20:13:00 UTC
Reply
I'll clear that up when I get home.
And Stinksap is a Potterverse thing. It was sprayed by Neville's Mimbulus Mimbletonia when he jabbed it with a quill. I'm sure there are other instances, but I'm drawing a blank right now. *hangs head in shame* -
If memory serves (and it may not...) by
on 2015-01-10 21:43:00 UTC
Reply
I think the twins use the stuff as an ingredient in one of their souped-up Dungbomb replacements at Weasley's Wizard Wheezes.
(NB: I really, REALLY hate it when people get the name wrong. I mean, it's a pun, gang, but it's a pun that Americans almost uniformly don't get so they just assume it was something different. IDK, maybe it's changed in the American editions or something, but it crops up everywhere in the Pit and it makes me want to stab stuff.) -
Huh? by
on 2015-01-10 22:44:00 UTC
Reply
When do people get the name wrong? Or rather, how? What name?
Sorry if I sound really derby right now, but I have no clue what you're talking about... :( -
Explanation time! by
on 2015-01-10 23:09:00 UTC
Reply
It has often been my experience that American authors call the Weasley twins' business "Weasley's Wizarding Wheezes". This is not what it's called, and the reason for that is that the phrase "wizard wheeze" is a slightly archaic term (I think it was used in the Just William books, but don't quote me on that) for a really good practical joke or prank of some description. Wizard Wheezes is the perfect name for the business, not least because it's something people have half a chance of getting in Diagon Alley and so forth. Changing it to Wizarding Wheezes, well... that irks.
Just a spot.
=] - People seriously call it that? by on 2015-01-10 23:32:00 UTC Reply
-
Nice work! by
on 2015-01-10 02:28:00 UTC
Reply
Rina and Randa are right, by the way; that foreshadowing is kind of unsubtle. (Also, I was confused when Rina used the DORKS to restore her disguise. When did the disguise drop?)
And...oh my Din, you're doing My Inner Life? Can I help in any possible capacity? I want to help Hyrule too! -
Re: Nice work! by
on 2015-01-10 03:32:00 UTC
Reply
Rina changed back to normal after the boat ride. And kind of unsubtle? It was about as subtle as a baseball bat to the face. >_>
As for My Inner Life *shudders*, Randa's got LoZ knowledge out the wazoo... but would you like to beta? I'd be honored. :3
Since I'm planning on tackling Little Miss Mary and Rose Potter further down the line, I figured a non-Legendary Badfic (how is it not, now that I think of it? I stumbled across it years ago) of epic proportions would be a nice starting point. -
Congrats on the mission! =] by
on 2015-01-09 16:43:00 UTC
Reply
It's pretty awesome, and it shows a good deal of courage to go through an old shame and have to read it critically, usually with a stiff drink and a therapist nearby.
One thing that struck me was that the D.O.R.K.S unit disguised itself as a copy of Magical Me, which seemed odd considering this is set in the Marauder era and the book wasn't published until the autumn of 1992. But then I realised; that's exactly the kind of totally minor deviation from canon that wouldn't upset the Words at all but a PPC agent would definitely notice. Good job. =] -
I wish I had a drink for this one. by
on 2015-01-09 17:24:00 UTC
Reply
But it's probably better to save it for the next mission- wait, crap, I'm too young to drink! D:
I just figured the D.O.R.K.S. was being stupid on purpose... ^_^' But we'll pretend your interpretation is what I planned. Yep. *grins sheepishly* -
In similar vein... by
on 2015-01-09 18:00:00 UTC
Reply
Regardless of the illegality, there's been no word on how well Bleeprin and related products work in regards to blood-alcohol content. It goes kaboomsky enough on the outside; its effects on one's arteries doesn't really bear thinking about.
But I am anyway.
I r smurt. -
Bleeprun is for people who can tolerate it. :P (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 19:25:00 UTC
Reply
-
...well, poop. It looks like I created a Bleeprin with legs. (nm by
on 2015-01-09 19:26:00 UTC
Reply
-
Hey, you could always use that! :P by
on 2015-01-10 21:47:00 UTC
Reply
Bleeprun! The Bleepproduct that comes to you! Of course, it's more likely to be the Bleepproduct you have to chase down. ;)
-
NOOO! I DON'T WANNA BE EATEN! *scampers off to hide* (nm) by
on 2015-01-10 22:42:00 UTC
Reply
-
Oooh, mobile Bleeproduce dispensers! by
on 2015-01-10 21:53:00 UTC
Reply
Nick a replicator or something similar from a sci-fi badfic, bolt some legs on it, have it run around to the RCs in question!
And have them look like this. =] -
I was imagining them as looking closer to mini-Luggages. by
on 2015-01-10 21:58:00 UTC
Reply
Probably with the same bad temper. I mean, would *you* be happy if you constantly had to give away your Bleeprin?
-
Quite literally, considering the typo in question. =] (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 22:31:00 UTC
Reply
-
Cathartic cringe by
on 2015-01-09 15:49:00 UTC
Reply
Rina's pain is so palpable I can't stop cringing. It makes for a unique mission, though, particularly the acknowledgments of when you did learn from your mistakes (and when you tried without understanding what actually made a Sue). Plus the resulting back-and-forth with the Agents is a lot of fun.
-
It's pretty obvious I had no idea what I was doing. by
on 2015-01-09 17:21:00 UTC
Reply
There were some things that I knew I had to avoid, like urple prose and tragic backstories, but that alone wasn't enough... >_>
Glad you enjoyed it! -
Good job! by
on 2015-01-09 04:21:00 UTC
Reply
The mission was very fun to read, though as a lover of terrible puns I didn't mind the Sirius/serious thing too much. I definitely relate to Rina's pain, though, and it's times like this I am happy none of my fics ever got past first chapters (and were all deleted years ago.)
-
Thank you :D (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 11:43:00 UTC
Reply
-
I've got a better Sirius pun. by
on 2015-01-09 03:19:00 UTC
Reply
"Are you serious?"
"Yes, I am. Oh, sorry, I thought you meant my name."
Not sure if it's funny, but it's probaby an improvement over what you had.
Why yes, I am a pun enthusiast. Puns are supposedy the lowest form of wit... but wit is the highest form of humor. -
They're simply punderbar! *is shot* by
on 2015-01-09 03:36:00 UTC
Reply
Bad jokes aside, it's nigh impossible to find a Marauders-era fic that doesn't use the Sirius/serious thing at least once. You'd be hard-pressed to come up with a variation that doesn't make most people just roll their eyes. If I ever rewrite that story, I'll most likely just cut them and save everyone the headache.
-
You should sometime. I'd like to see how you'd save it! by
on 2015-01-09 03:46:00 UTC
Reply
I would've done the same thing with "Rise of the Galeforces" myself, but sadly, I have never had the time to write any fanfic since my graduate degrees and it was doomed from the beginning anyway. At least in your case you stuck to a single continuum.
But anyway, I think it would be an interesting idea to try writing about a fifth marauder in a more realistic way, and possibly explore what happened to her and why they don't mention her in canon. It'll be hard, of course, but maybe it'll be a worthwhile investment. Maybe... -
Well... (Also, mini alert!) by
on 2015-01-09 04:48:00 UTC
Reply
(*ushers marauder to the HFA*)
The plan I had from the beginning involved time travel and alternate timelines, but it required a Time-Turner. This wouldn't have been a problem, but JKR recently said on Pottermore that Time-Turners can go back only a few hours.
Not to mention I kind of stole an idea from A:TLA and the Sue also needed those stupid prophetic dreams in order to motivate her... I don't know. It would take a lot of finnageling. Which is sad, because I had ideas on how another Marauder would have an impact on Harry's story. -
Niiiiice~! by
on 2015-01-09 02:59:00 UTC
Reply
I was actually reminded of my very first PPC mission while reading this - though to be fair, I sporked that 35-chapter horror story specifically to clear my name as a writer and to give Falchion a jump-start on character development. Yours comes off as more of a "Why not tackle an old shames for spits and giggles?" kind of deal, which isn't a bad thing.
And dear Arceus, "My Inner Life"? Oh wow, you have my sympathies. *virtual hugs* Godspeed, you two, and may you have Farore's blessing (and a firm grip on your sanity!)! -
*accepts hug* by
on 2015-01-09 03:31:00 UTC
Reply
I'd been looking forward to sporking my old shame, and the deed is at last complete!
But yeah, My Inner Life... *shudders* The badly-written sex scenes, atrocious grammar, and utter Suishness were horrible enough on their own, but poor (RL) Randa has it way worse... she's a major LoZ fan, so this one hits her harder than it does me.
