Subject: Isn't that abusing PPC technology? (nm)
Author:
Posted on: 2012-09-15 02:55:00 UTC
-
You may be interested in this. by
on 2012-09-14 03:22:00 UTC
Reply
A certain Sherlock/Hitchhiker's Guide crossover fic has caught my attention. So far it is only one chapter in length, but I'm keeping an eye on it. It has the potential to turn into a rather large mess. <br> The grammar is almost passable at moments, but a great deal of it turns into this: "You have no information except that last you heard he was in London? Lost contact for at least three year. Well it's better than anything I heard all week but first we must wait for John to show. He has two minutes judging by the last time this happened."<br> Then there is the matter of Trillian being renamed Zooey, and having the unfortunate occupation of: "actress, fashion icon and superstar."<br> I'm thinking of posting a short review with con. criticism. Should I wait for it to spiral downwards before officially reporting it, or drop the link here for reference? I'm not sure if there's a procedure for this. -
Who knows Halo, Sonic, and Kingdom Hearts? by
on 2012-09-15 23:48:00 UTC
Reply
Because I have crossovers for all 3, and I know nothing about them.
http://www.fanfiction.net/s/6966278/1/TSAB-DOWNFALL-Halo-War
Nanoha/Halo crossover, bereft of logic. So, apparently after the Jail Scaglietti incident, the TSAB decides, in order to protect the galaxy from a threat that isn't there, to lift the ban on mass-based weaponry (one of the biggest taboos, and completely unnecessary since magical weapons are safer, more controllable, and better in general), release the guy who held the ENTIRE CAPITAL PLANET hostage, and let him continue his combat cyborg work. Only Nanoha and the Saint King church, apparently, oppose this. Not Fate, who HOME RUN'd Jail into a wall, not Subaru, who IS a combat cyborg whose sister was BRAINWASHED into serving Jail, and who idolizes Nanoha, and not Hayate, who is pretty much the adopted sister of the Church's head. And after this, Nanoha is apparently killed after being hit with a ton of Arc-en-Ciels, yet something called a 'Forerunner' revives her, gives her a speshul makeover (she gets heterochromia [is she now a descendant of the Shutran Hegemon now?], white hair, a seventeen-year-old body, and loses the 'hair on her more private areas of her body'.) Help.
http://www.fanfiction.net/s/7294471/1/FORERUNNER-Advent-Magica
Halo x Madoka Magica crossover by the same guy as above. Some kind of ship gets to Mitakihara, enters a Barrier (impossible unless the Witch tries to eat you or you're a Puella) and... I don't know if the ship-teleporting is possible. Someone who knows Halo, please look at this.
http://www.fanfiction.net/s/7529122/1/Sonics-Last-Wish
Obviously, a Sonic x Madoka crossover. Admittedly, I don't know Sonic, but I do know that the main character is MALE. And yet, he is a Puella Magi. Toss in some replacement!Kyubey and this is a pretty annoying but not godawful oneshot.
http://www.fanfiction.net/s/8432279/1/Certain-as-the-Sun
Kingdom Hearts, Madoka Magica, and Beauty and the Beast. In this, KYOUKO, the street-child, orphan, who cares almost nothing for her fellow humans, who is violent and food-obsessed, is Belle. ICE CREAM is her equivalent of Belle's books, and the metaphor DOES NOT WORK. For one, Kyouko starved as a child, and Belle never had to scrounge for books and read books out of the trash and steal them from convenience stores to survive. Second, whoever 'Seifer' is (he takes the place of Gaston), he should be pinned to a wall with a spear, surrounded by rubble, for taking Kyoko's food. -
Oh, gods... by
on 2012-09-16 21:49:00 UTC
Reply
Nanoha also gets unbreakable bones, an infodump on history, and a new 'Forerunner' style magic that can only be used lethally.
-
I know something about Halo. by
on 2012-09-17 11:47:00 UTC
Reply
1) Haloverse? No magic at all. Forerunners DON'T. HAVE. MAGIC. Just superadvanced technology.
2) Halo ship entering Madokaverse barriers? WTF? Most Halo ships are enough big to not fit inside at all. (Hell, the Pillar Of Autumn is big enough to fit several Nanohaverse ships in its cargo bay.)
3) Nanoha fighting agains all of her old friends and TSAB going back to mass-based weapons? Ripped from the famous "BetrayerS" doujin.
Madoka-dammit, when will the powerlevels of those crossover stop going up? We had to use an Arc-En-Ciel to get rid of the last Nanoha-crossover super-special Sue. (to be released when we find enough betas)
Now we have a replacement Nanoha who survived SEVERAL of them. -
Ok, fine by
on 2012-09-16 15:00:00 UTC
Reply
It does say that a 'coup de tat' overthrew the TSAB's government (somehow) while keeping control of all the planets, the army, and keepin the council system of government. Ignoring the civil war likely to come from such a coup, this means that, not only are Fate, Subaru, and Hayate going against their friend and siding with their hated enemy, they're also obeying the people who overthrew the government!
-
Okay, the Fics Under Surveillance page is a-go! (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 07:09:00 UTC
Reply
-
Oh you are gorgeous by
on 2012-09-16 00:49:00 UTC
Reply
Thank you Kitty!
-
You're welcome! (nm) by
on 2012-09-16 01:33:00 UTC
Reply
-
Hooray! by
on 2012-09-15 23:35:00 UTC
Reply
I've just dumped a bunch of crossovers and fanfics that've been sitting in my bookmarks for a while.
-
Hmmm... by
on 2012-09-16 16:15:00 UTC
Reply
I'd remove Midoriya Mania and Material Madness.
While they aren't exceptionally good grammar-wise, they kinda managed to make me laugh, which is what they were supposed to do in the first places (being parody crackfics and all), and the author seems open to concrit.
Besides, Midoriya Mania sounds like a one-shot (and so is probably too short for a mission or a MST). -
I noticed! by
on 2012-09-16 01:33:00 UTC
Reply
Thankies so much for the adds - the page is looking more and more official!
-
Well Done! by
on 2012-09-15 16:26:00 UTC
Reply
I like it. Very thorough.
-
-blush- by
on 2012-09-15 19:16:00 UTC
Reply
It's the best I could do at twelve in the morning...It's very heavily based off the Unclaimed Badfic page - in some areas I only changed a word or two - and I didn't add any categories under the headings.
But thankies for the compliment! -
Wait... by
on 2012-09-15 19:21:00 UTC
Reply
Twelve in the morning? like, 1200, or 0000?
/cannot into time zones and/or doesn't know where anybody lives. -
Uh... by
on 2012-09-15 19:33:00 UTC
Reply
Which one is 0000 in UTC? Because I didn't bookmark the graph I found...
Okay, I think I remember 6:33 UTC being 10:33 PST, and I put that marker down before I was actually finished with the page...
Anyway, midnight. Late. (At least, it was near eleven when I finished, and honestly I don't remember actually making the page or writing the 'page is up' post here, except the computer is adamant that I did both...) -
Oh. So 0000, then by
on 2012-09-15 19:40:00 UTC
Reply
Sorry, I've gotten in the habit of using Zulu time (24 hour) instead of 'normal.' I confuse less easily about when I'm to do what that way.
-
By the way by
on 2012-09-15 20:11:00 UTC
Reply
Do you have Permission yet, or d'you have to wait a bit more? I found a short little unfinished Lioness fic that's making steam come out my ears. The MC's such a massive Sue I can barely wrap my head around it.
-
Oh really? by
on 2012-09-15 20:28:00 UTC
Reply
I don't have Permission just yet - I'm still working the kinks out of my character bios and the writing sample. I may be ready by Wednesday, though. Do you have a link in the meantime?
-
'Ere we go by
on 2012-09-15 20:31:00 UTC
Reply
Link : http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2310723/1/Princess-Knight
Read it and be infuriated.
(I just realized I doubleposted part of that last post. Whoopsie) -
IMPORTANT by
on 2012-09-16 12:13:00 UTC
Reply
Princess Knight has been reported and is on the Unclaimed Badfic page. If it's going to be sporked i should be removed from there first.
-
Understood. (nm) by
on 2012-09-16 21:52:00 UTC
Reply
-
Gateth of Naxen? by
on 2012-09-16 01:32:00 UTC
Reply
Uhm...are there minis for the Pierce'verse? Because I think that's supposed to be Duke Gareth I of Naxen...
Yup, mini-Stormwings. Eek... -
Oh yeah. by
on 2012-09-16 03:59:00 UTC
Reply
Mini-Stormwings out the wazoo. Among other things.
-
As if the big ones aren't enough of a hassle... (nm) by
on 2012-09-16 05:35:00 UTC
Reply
-
0000? by
on 2012-09-15 20:06:00 UTC
Reply
Wait, so then 10:33 pm isn't 6:33 UTC?
UTC time confuses me... -
While I'm here, by
on 2012-09-15 20:28:00 UTC
Reply
Do you have Permission yet, or d'you have to wait a bit more? I found a short little unfinished Lioness fic that's making steam come out my ears. The MC's such a massive Sue I can barely wrap my head around it.
I mean, I'm having to restrain myself from writing a Charge List already. This [profanity] does ruddy BACKFLIPS during training duels, and flips people's swords out of their hands and catches them, and is a whiny delicate princess who goes on at length about how STRONG and INDEPENDENT she is while mentally whingeing about not having servants, and...and...Oh, right, utterly fracks up almost ALL of the characters she meets (except Ralon, but he's a jerk anyway), completely ignores and sort of realism at all in regards to international relations (unidentified Gallan nobles do NOT just get invited into the castle by random gate guards to train as a TORTALLAN knight, for Mithros' sake)...etc. Plus the normal urple prose, bad spelling, and abhorrent grammar. -
Never mind. I just meant 'at night' instead of ''midday' (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 20:12:00 UTC
Reply
-
Ooh look guys, a troll author again by
on 2012-09-14 21:22:00 UTC
Reply
Except this one really hits me hard because this one Hetalia trollfic oh Frah.
And I thought my Wales OC was bad... I just... *flails around for a moment*
Just
http://www.fanfiction.net/u/4055260/littlestpetshop2000
*gross sobbing*
We have Hetalia, Homestuck and some Homestuck/Legend of Zelda crossovers.
I looked at the two Hetalia ones and oh Frah someone please hand me some Bleeprin that Wales has ruined my ability to English and grammar and punctuation.And whoops I haven't been on in a while, I need to get back into the habit of coming here -
Uh, what the fruk did I just read by
on 2012-09-15 07:56:00 UTC
Reply
Seriously, what the fruk was that
/downs all the Bleepka -
Here, have some Bleepolate, too. (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 08:08:00 UTC
Reply
-
It'll be okay. by
on 2012-09-15 00:23:00 UTC
Reply
Here, have some Bleepolate. It'll make you feel better. -pats you on the back-
-
Thank you... by
on 2012-09-15 12:01:00 UTC
Reply
I just... my country... *sobs and eats Bleepolate*
-
-hugs you sympathetically- (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 19:17:00 UTC
Reply
-
Dear God by
on 2012-09-14 22:20:00 UTC
Reply
Just looking at the story descriptions alone was enough for me. I didn't even open a single fic.
I just..what is this I don't even...
*takes a slug of Bleepka straight from the bottle*
If I knew the canons better, I wold write a mission or three. And the Link/Karkat bit makes me nauseous. -
Yes by
on 2012-09-14 03:49:00 UTC
Reply
Link it, so that we may satisfy our curiosity. Depending on the AUGH-Factor, I'd hold off on "officially" reporting it for now - unless, that is, it truly is that bad.
-
Uhm... by
on 2012-09-14 03:47:00 UTC
Reply
That sounds rather...frightening.
Out of morbid curiosity alone, I would say post the link to it so we have an idea of what you've discovered (not that your summary hasn't already thoroughly put me on edge).
Also, is there a 'Fics Under Surveillance' page on the wiki? -
Not per se (nm) by
on 2012-09-14 03:51:00 UTC
Reply
-
Not that I've seen, no. by
on 2012-09-14 03:51:00 UTC
Reply
I'll keep scouring the wiki though. Well, here it is: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/8148497/1/JohnWatsonOrArthurDent
-
In regards to the under-surveillance page... by
on 2012-09-14 04:36:00 UTC
Reply
If there isn't, maybe there should be one for cases such as this one? I mean, I don't know how frequent they are, but it seems to me it couldn't hurt to have somewhere to list any and all fics we find that need to have someone keeping an eye on them. If not a Wiki page, at the very least a link page on LiveJournal or sommat so everyone can keep tabs now and then...
Also, wow. That...that is bad. Not legendarily bad, but, yeah, it's got potential. -
You see my dilemma. by
on 2012-09-14 04:39:00 UTC
Reply
So, shall we talk with the higher-ups about making said page?
-
Indeed I do. by
on 2012-09-14 04:41:00 UTC
Reply
-gasp- You mean I (we) get to suggest a big change to the Wiki...to the guys in charge?
-feints, wakes up and squeals-
Let's! -
Well, by
on 2012-09-14 04:43:00 UTC
Reply
I imagine we need to find a suitable way to bring the matter to their attention.
-
Department of Intelligence, at your service. by
on 2012-09-14 05:01:00 UTC
Reply
I remember Huinesoron telling someone that you can type up an Intel-style report even without Permission (but you can't write about the adventures the spy has within the story).
The "Intel stub" should follow the template found on the Wiki, minus the topmost section.
/shameless attempt in reviving an almost dead Department -
Almost-Dead?! by
on 2012-09-14 05:06:00 UTC
Reply
Be that the case or no, that simply will not do! after I get Permission and write a mission or two with my initial pair, I'll have to make an agent for the DoI, too.
(Plus, it seems kind of fun.) -
The thing about the DoI... by
on 2012-09-14 06:21:00 UTC
Reply
...is that--in my mind--you can write a lot more about life in HQ with the agents. Since Intel is an infrastructure department, you can get a sort of "nine-to-five" feel out of it since surveillance work isn't always as hectic as the life of an Action agent.
It's quite fun being the only person who writes for the DoI, but the other half of the fun is seeing how others use your ideas in their spinoffs.
Speaking of which, is it just me or am I noticing people mention Intel reports a lot more in recent missions? -
I've been making plans for an Infrastructure character by
on 2012-09-14 15:27:00 UTC
Reply
And yes, I mean in pretty much every Infrastructure department (except for FIcPsych and Medical.) The character is supposed to be a person with a bunch of bodies--they're all identical, and she controls each one, sort of thing. Thing is, the agent doesn't get any of the normal advantages to being in multiple places at once--she can't make them appear or disappear, and she has almost no physical endurance or strength. So she does Infrastructure.
-
Which is neat, I think. by
on 2012-09-14 08:07:00 UTC
Reply
And I've noticed that, too. Maybe everyone's collectively deciding to give the DoI some love?
-
I have an DoI Agent to turn loose: by
on 2012-09-14 06:17:00 UTC
Reply
Officer Rooney. He was recruited from Ellie and Chrissy's Laura Adler mission because he had the beginnings of a personality that wasn't exactly terrible. That's to say, he's patronising as hell but he's a strong believer in Sherlock Holmes, so he wasn't that bad of a character.
I thought about putting him, post-recruitment, in DMS, but he's middle-aged and probably eager for a less violent job. So DoI it is.
If anyone wants to use him, go right ahead. -
Ah, yes. by
on 2012-09-14 04:46:00 UTC
Reply
Does the Board not qualify? Where/how shall we go about this if that is the case?
And no, I am not bouncing with nervousness. Shush. -
Settle down, I'm just not sure if they'll see this. by
on 2012-09-14 04:49:00 UTC
Reply
If they do, that's wonderful! I suppose we wait a day or two before bringing it up again.
-
Ye gods and little fishies. by
on 2012-09-14 21:25:00 UTC
Reply
Okay, let me just... um...
Um.
Repeat after me. Out loud, if you can.
There are no PPC Higher Ups.
None! We are a community of equals. Authority exists only where utterly impossible to avoid - in the case of Permission Givers, we really have no authority outside of giving permission. The Nameless Admin is nameless specifically to avoid giving their word weight in conversations outside of technical issues. On the IRC, the DAs' authority exists only to stop things getting out of hand, and the mods/admins/whatever-they're-called only exist to deal with trolls and Serious Problems. Sometimes, having been around a bit longer means people listen to you more (see: the Huinesoron Effect), but that's an illusion, more or less, entirely due to the level that people ...well, listen to you more. Someone who's been around for six months and done a ton of hands-on work with the Wiki has more pull concerning the Wiki than does someone who's been around for seven years and only ever touched it with a ten-foot pole.
So, you see, putting a thread on the 'Board and hoping that some authority figure will come start a Thing is a futile hope - you're only going to get crazy Bogdanovists like me to tell you the Vor system is an illusion, or people like hS to wave their arms frantically and go "I'm not in charge! Stop looking at me!"
If you think a change should be made, this is exactly(-ish) the way to go about it. Either 1) create the article yourself, and then, through the wiki page* or the 'Board, let people know about it, and ask for help and contributions and/or opinions. Or 2) ask people about what they think about creating said wiki page.
And, voila! The page is officially created. It's much better than a bureaucracy, don't you think?
(You may also have created a new secret identity for me, for which I must thank you. Next time, somebody just wave the Bogdanovist Spotlight around.)
*probably recommended, since that's where the Wiki-Involved People will definitely see it - on the 'Board, you're getting the Board side of the Triple Venn Diagram** of PPCers, on the Wiki, you're getting the Wiki side. Which is what you want, for New Article Teams.
**Three overlapping circles - the 'Board community, the IRC community, and the Wiki community. Sorta. But I think they make a bit more sense in an extra dimension, since you get people who are Wiki-and-IRC but don't check the 'Board, and people who're 'Board-and-IRC but don't touch the Wiki, and people who're Wiki-and-Board but never bother with the IRC. And people who do all three, and people who do just one, though that's discouraged (especially for the Wiki). -
/is properly chastened by
on 2012-09-15 02:37:00 UTC
Reply
Thanks for the information! It's always great to know more about a subject you're invested in.
-
Too true! by
on 2012-09-15 03:14:00 UTC
Reply
And before this subject goes to dust - or becomes otherwise uninteresting, which is always a possibility - I shall ask the question on my mind: Since there seem to be mostly positive responses to the under-surveillance page idea, shall we create one?
-
So we shall! by
on 2012-09-15 03:16:00 UTC
Reply
Now, how do we do it?
-
-squeaks- by
on 2012-09-15 03:21:00 UTC
Reply
...Er, -squeals-, rather...
Hmm...Well, we should look at how the Unclaimed Badfic, Claimed Badfic, and Kill Badfic pages are set up, and try to base the new page off of that. And...hmm, maybe the page should be something like, "Fics Under Surveillance" or "Under-Surveillance Fics" or something like that.
You want me to start working on the page, or...what're we doing from here? -
Hmm by
on 2012-09-15 03:59:00 UTC
Reply
Well, I'm on my mobile. I also happen to have no access to a computer, so it might be a bit difficult for me to contribute. I can try though...
-
How 'bout this: by
on 2012-09-15 04:01:00 UTC
Reply
I'll start things off, and then you can help fix anything that may need fixing. Yes?
-
*Grins* by
on 2012-09-15 04:09:00 UTC
Reply
Knock yourself out.
-
Oi! by
on 2012-09-15 04:11:00 UTC
Reply
No wishing physical damage on other PPCers! (And your stupid bucket o' water gave me a concussion anyway, remember? Knocking myself unconscious would be a Very Bad Thing to do with a concussion.)
-
Me? Wish ill? by
on 2012-09-15 04:24:00 UTC
Reply
You wound me. That hurts, implying I'd ever want to see somebody hurt! ..Weeell, apart from Sues. And the occasional Author whose work is bad enough that I wish they were deader than Horus. But apart from that, neh.
-
I can see devil horns holding up your halo. (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 04:39:00 UTC
Reply
-
No idea what you're talking about *whistles innocently* (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 04:46:00 UTC
Reply
-
Your pants are aflame again. (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 04:48:00 UTC
Reply
-
*Chuckles* by
on 2012-09-15 03:33:00 UTC
Reply
You may find this helpful.
http://ppc.wikia.com/wiki/Help:Editing
Happy writing! -
Point taken. by
on 2012-09-14 21:53:00 UTC
Reply
There are no PPC Higher Ups.
...Well, you said to repeat after you... -
Yeah, it takes some getting used to by
on 2012-09-14 22:14:00 UTC
Reply
IT really does. Don't fret, we all have to figure stuff out when we first get here. Just part of the learning process.
-
I'm getting better every day! (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 00:19:00 UTC
Reply
-
And so is he! by
on 2012-09-15 01:47:00 UTC
Reply
And so are we all!
(But really, Riese, you were the one who replied with "The oldbies say it's okay." I saw that. :P) -
......*Neuralizes* by
on 2012-09-15 02:11:00 UTC
Reply
You saw nothing. I didn't post anything about any oldbie anything. Nothing to see here, these aren't the droids you're looking for, move along.
That is all. -
Isn't that abusing PPC technology? (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 02:55:00 UTC
Reply
-
*glances around* by
on 2012-09-15 03:21:00 UTC
Reply
W-what are you t-talking about? I d-didn't do anything...
*whistles* -
Liar, liar... by
on 2012-09-15 03:24:00 UTC
Reply
Pantalones del fuego!
(Yes, I just copied Dr. Doofenschmirtz. WHAT.) -
AUGH! by
on 2012-09-15 03:30:00 UTC
Reply
Owwie, owwie, OWWIE!
*Flails around trying to put out pants*
*Realizes pants are burned up*
.....
*Hides*
Why would you do that? Jeez, you better watch it with the Flamer, the Flowers might start getting flashbacks.
Oh, and if you feel the urge to shout, "Mr. Rogers! Mr. Rogers!" just put the Flamer down and take some deep breaths while FicPsych comes with the special jacket... -
-creepy angelic smile- (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 03:34:00 UTC
Reply
-
*edges away* by
on 2012-09-15 03:36:00 UTC
Reply
Ahm...Guys? I...I think we may have a sliiiiiight problem here.....
*sneaks out the door and runs for the RC* -
I thought only agents had RCs? by
on 2012-09-15 03:40:00 UTC
Reply
Problem? There's no problem here. -'nother creepy smile-
-
*skids to a halt* by
on 2012-09-15 03:42:00 UTC
Reply
R-right. Only Agents have-
uh.
Only Agents...
uh...heh heh heh...heh heh HEEEEELP!
*Runs some more* -
-skips merrily after you- by
on 2012-09-15 03:51:00 UTC
Reply
Whee, I like tormenting people~!
-
I swear to... by
on 2012-09-15 03:54:00 UTC
Reply
*Nails Kitty with a bucket of water I pulled out of the Hammerspace in my Dresden duster*
There. No more fire. *sticks tongue out at Kit* -
-grins outright- by
on 2012-09-15 03:56:00 UTC
Reply
Ah, but now I have a bucket...and also a concussion...Ow...
-
*Facepalms* by
on 2012-09-15 04:00:00 UTC
Reply
Right, Note to Self: Never let go of the ruddy bucket when you go to hit somebody with it. Uhm, uhm, crap.
*Runs like blue fookin' blazes and hides*
(You're fun. You ever want somebody to team up for a mission, let me know.) -
Tee-hee. by
on 2012-09-15 04:04:00 UTC
Reply
-staggering around psuedo-drunkenly- Like I could hit you when I'm seeing two of everything...
(I know, you too. We can co-write or something.) -
Wait a sec. by
on 2012-09-15 04:07:00 UTC
Reply
You're seeing double? Crap. Uhm...I didn't think I hit you THAT hard...Sorry? Please don't incinerate me?
-
As soon as the two of you stop dancing around in circles... by
on 2012-09-15 04:12:00 UTC
Reply
...I may return the favor. Which one's the real you?
-
*Raises eyebrow, Spock-like* by
on 2012-09-15 04:17:00 UTC
Reply
Why, clearly the more dashing, handsome, and charming one. I mean, can't you tell?
*Ducks bucket* Or that one. That one works too. *Ducks again and runs* -
You realize you just turned into Spock for a second, right? by
on 2012-09-15 04:23:00 UTC
Reply
Ha-HA! C'mere, Riese, I want to introduce you to Mister Bucket! -gives chase-
-
So...much...running by
on 2012-09-15 04:25:00 UTC
Reply
Kit, you are *pant* acting most *pant* illogical!
*Sets Phaser (woo, more Hammerspace!) to 'Annoy' and fires over shoulder* -
You hit the bucket! by
on 2012-09-15 04:42:00 UTC
Reply
Oh, nice going, Spockabee. Now the bucket's singing "It's A Small World" chipmunk-style.
-
*cough* by
on 2012-09-15 04:40:00 UTC
Reply
And this is the part where I direct you to the top of the 'Board, which says:
-The PPC IRC is the place for idle conversation. If it's just a few people talking, it's best to take it to the IRC.
KittyNoodles, have you checked out the IRC for ridiculous and fun banter (and avoidance of Board-stretching) yet? -
-deep breaths- by
on 2012-09-14 04:50:00 UTC
Reply
That sounds like a good idea - as active as the Board's been, they're probably watching it a bit more frequently. Or as frequently as ever. -shrugs-
-
Re: -deep breaths- by
on 2012-09-14 04:53:00 UTC
Reply
The Powers that Be (Not the Flowers, the Oldbies) aren't against it. Wikify to your heart's content, guys/gals!
-
Im'ma defer to IntelligentAirhead on this one. by
on 2012-09-14 04:56:00 UTC
Reply
You take the lead, I shall follow along helpfully.
-
Oh, dear. by
on 2012-09-14 04:00:00 UTC
Reply
I see what you mean; this one certainly DOES have potential, doesn't it, then? "I'll text you if anyone starts to trail us."
Texting. In 19th Century England. *Cocks shotgun*
Also, the MC seems a tad Sue-ish.
Yeah, I'd definitely keep an eye on this one. -
Sorry Riese, but this is BBC Sherlock. by
on 2012-09-14 04:06:00 UTC
Reply
I should have stated the situation clearly. This is BBC Sherlock, a modern adaptation of Sherlock Holmes. It is a popular television show. The fic has many errors, but the mobile isn't one of them.
-
Oh. Well, then. by
on 2012-09-14 04:14:00 UTC
Reply
I'm afraid I am sadly unfamiliar with this adaptation. Does Sherlock habitually refer to everyone by their first name, too?
-
He is a jerk to everyone he meets, so... by
on 2012-09-14 04:28:00 UTC
Reply
Oh dear, brace yourselves.
The modern version of Sherlock Holmes can be very mercurial. He tends to go with what comes naturally to him. In most cases this means he is blunt, condescending, and unable to understand the sensitivity of other's. He is willing to show off for anyone, and shows many traits similar to those with Asperger's Syndrome; however, these are exaggerated for entertainment purposes. He shows less compassion than even the original character, and refers to himself as a highly functioning sociopath. This does not seem to fit his psychological profile, so we'll chalk that up to his many years of being called a freak. He tends to tell people to shut up when they aren't talking, derive enjoyment from petty revenge, and act like a prodigal six year old. All of this is an integral part of his personality, and yet many fangirls idolise him anyway. Subsequently, many get it into their heads that their Mary Sues can change him for he better.
This has been a rant on the characterisation of BBC universe's Sherlock. Have a nice day, and please do take our complimentary bag of peanuts. -
I applaud you. by
on 2012-09-15 00:41:00 UTC
Reply
Yeah, the Aspergers symptoms are a bit overplayed (usually) but I always read that as him being more outrageous than usual so that he wouldn't be ordinary. Most people learn coping mechanisms: he seems to be avoiding that.
And the Mary Sues are stupid, because if he wanted to change, he would have done it for a)John b)His family or Mrs Hudson c) Lestrade so that he would be more welcome at Scotland Yard. So clearly, his current lack of connectivity to the ordinary people of London is not of any concern to him.
This has been a complimentary rant. Pass the peanuts. -
Chuck me some peanuts. by
on 2012-09-15 16:19:00 UTC
Reply
I'm just going to say that the majority of Sherlock Sues I've seen (and I have seen a shitload of them now) function under the idea that "girls want a bad boy who's willing to be good for them", under the appeal of Boyce Avenue's cover of Katy Perry's "Teenage Dream" (instead of being all about sex, the BA cover is all about cuddling around and having deep romantic connections. yeah. it's very nice).
That is to say, any bad boy like Sherlock or Moriarty (and by bad I mean cynical about society, possible sociopathy, etc) can be turned into a loving, caring ideal mate of the Sue's at the cost of believable characterisation. Because, believe me, there is a way to write lovey-dovey Moriarty and it's "as a psychopathic act". And there is a way to write a caring Sherlock and it's "Three Garridebs, with Watson being hurt".
Key term: Watson. Because to me, any Sue who attempts to be with Sherlock Holmes is upstaging John Watson. Even if John is straight and Sherlock is asexual (popular headcanon, especially given the married-to-his-work spiel), there is still an element of their bromance that goes deeper than such. Neither can exist without the other - their post-FALL characterisations in the last minutes of the show clearly say that. John's entire dating career has been trainwrecked by Sherlock, and Sherlock is entirely uninterested in something as vapid as dating girls.
So if a Sue tries to change that, they change a huge part of Sherlock's character.
(Pardon my heteronormative language, but we /are/ discussing Suvian stereotypes in the BBC Sherlock fandom and heteronormativity tends to happen with Sues around.) -
*passes the popcorn* by
on 2012-09-15 19:31:00 UTC
Reply
I dunno if this is the case with the BBC Sherlock, but I know that in the original Conan Doyle work, the only woman Holmes ever cared about was the one from "A Scandal in Bohemia." And the only reason he cared about her was purely professional admiration; she was the only person ever to "beat" him.
TL;DR, Holmes doesn't give a rip about any woman who can't beat him at his own game. -
/noms popcorn and peanuts by
on 2012-09-15 22:46:00 UTC
Reply
(Spoilers like woah below)
In BBC, Sherlock only beats Irene after Mycroft hands it over to him on a silver platter that he's been duped. It's a twist stolen right from the Private Life of Sherlock Holmes. And while fandom may cry sexist for Sherlock saving Irene at the very end, I personally think he was returning the favour - she did save him and John at the beginning of the episode, at the pool.
The only other female figure that Sherlock is shown to care about (in whatever way he shows that care) is Mrs Hudson. She's the only one who gets to hug him onscreen without repercussions. All the other female characters he belittles, and while he does tell Molly Hooper (who has a huge crush on him) that she matters to him, it's also in light of him needing a favour from her so I doubt that it was wholly genuine.
TL;DR: There are only three friends in BBC Sherlock's circle, and they are Mrs H, John, and Lestrade. And two out of three of those friends he constantly insults and belittles. Finding the space to care about a female love interest will burst his little heart. :'D -
Right. by
on 2012-09-15 22:52:00 UTC
Reply
So we can conclude that any 'fics that include Sherlock falling in love with/caring about/giving the time of day to any OC means he's rather thoroughly OOC, then?
-
I have only seen one OC that does it right. by
on 2012-09-15 22:58:00 UTC
Reply
And Sherlock's not even in love with her; he just respects her because she's the mathematician who created a keycode that Moriarty had been after in the Reichenbach Fall. It's the whole genius-respects-genius thing, and the fic centres on their destroying all traces of this keycode (it's a fill-in-the-Great-Hiatus fic) to make sure Moriarty's network don't get their fingers on it again.
The author says it'll be Sherlock/OC, but so far there's no romance and I wouldn't be averse to seeing it later on, because Sherlock is extremely believable in this fic.
More tl;dr: It takes a hell lot of writing skills to make him give a shit about an OC without being OOC, and the vast majority of OC writers Do It Wrong. -
Well, it's just as you said by
on 2012-09-15 23:44:00 UTC
Reply
The way to Sherlock's heart is not his stomach. Or being cute. Or singing. Or anything else of that ilk. It's by being as smart as/smarter than him, or something more along those lines. Suethors don't write like that because they want their character to be pretty, not brainy. AND WHO CARES IF HE WOULDN'T FALL FOR HER, IT's CALLED FANFICTION FOR A REASON, AND IT'S MY FIC, SO WHAT I SAY GOES!
...
*BLAM!* -
*and the peanuts. But have some popcorn, too!* (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 19:32:00 UTC
Reply
-
Consider the peanuts dispensed (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 02:39:00 UTC
Reply
-
Emperor preserve us by
on 2012-09-14 04:48:00 UTC
Reply
The whole thing sounds like one huge badfic. I get the feeling that if one was to point a CAD at Mr. Holmes, it's have an aneurism.
-
You should see the first Sue!fic I helped spork. by
on 2012-09-14 04:51:00 UTC
Reply
It's a little ways down the board. The Sue made Sherlock grow queasy at a crime scene. This is definitely at least 53% out of character and climbing.
-
Urgh by
on 2012-09-14 04:54:00 UTC
Reply
Yeah, I read it. Didn't really have much to say that others hadn' already, but...yeah.
-
I'm just waiting for a legendary badfic to appear. by
on 2012-09-14 04:58:00 UTC
Reply
This particular fandom is lacking one so far.
-
Just go read Topless Robot's Fan Fiction Friday by
on 2012-09-15 17:36:00 UTC
Reply
You're bound to find one that fits.
-
Back in MY day... by
on 2012-09-14 05:02:00 UTC
Reply
The older Boarders used to send newbies off to read the LB's as a sort of Rite of Passage. I must've killed at least two or three bottles of Bleeprin on C***br**n alone, let alone the others.
-
Tut! As if we ever would. by
on 2012-09-15 13:28:00 UTC
Reply
The Boarders of the PPC have far too much integrity to ever engage in such wanton cruelty to fresh-faced new members of our illustrious community even if their reactions are - I mean would be - hilarious.
hS -
I actually tried reading C*l*br**n on my own... by
on 2012-09-16 01:37:00 UTC
Reply
...To avoid being caught off-gaurd by any 'helpful' suggestions to read it and see what the PPC deals with.
I got through two-thirds of it before I burst into tears, broke the 'X' button on my Internet window, and spent the next three or four days watching and reading wholesome, canonical Lord of the Rings. -
....*shakes head sadly and offers Bleepka* (nm) by
on 2012-09-16 04:01:00 UTC
Reply
-
-chugs- by
on 2012-09-16 05:40:00 UTC
Reply
I'm glad I didn't know about Bleepuvor at that point - hallucinating about Elrond scolding me for OD'ing on the stuff might have broken my mind...
-
Worse than C**eb***n did?? by
on 2012-09-16 05:50:00 UTC
Reply
Is that even possible?
-
Pffthahahaha (nm) by
on 2012-09-15 16:18:00 UTC
Reply
-
I've hear of that one. by
on 2012-09-14 05:07:00 UTC
Reply
I'm surprised we haven't been hazed with a dose of Dipper Goes to Taco Bell. I read My Immortal two or three years back, but I still have quite a few legendaries to knock out.
-
Ehehe by
on 2012-09-14 05:15:00 UTC
Reply
Don't feel obligated to read them. Honestly, there are a few (C***b***n ESPECIALLY) that are genuinely okay-bro-roll-for-SAN-loss bad.
Also, if you look up-thread a bit, Kitty wants you to do the Wiki article. -
*heard (nm) by
on 2012-09-14 05:08:00 UTC
Reply
-
By that last remark, I meant the current fic. by
on 2012-09-14 04:52:00 UTC
Reply
I should not have attached that line to the end.