Subject: There, was that so hard?
Author:
Posted on: 2016-07-01 22:48:00 UTC

I disagree with you in part about Granny, and since disagreement with explanation is an excellent way to continue a conversation (as opposed to, say, 'you're wrong' and nothing more), I'll clarify why.

Granny was always about the headology, and that works best when you know the person. Think of all those conversations she had, often reported, with the people of Lancre - all the little details she sprinkled in to manipulate them into doing what's best for them.

I think if Granny went bad, she would've taken over Lancre, absolutely; but beyond the borders? I doubt it. She doesn't know those people. Think of what Lily did - she picked a city, and she moulded it to her own ends.

If Granny was going to expand, she'd do so sideways. I can't imagine her trying to conquer Ankh-Morpork... but I can absolutely see her taking over/down Elfland. They're a danger; there would be... a reckoning.

As to President Pickles, we don't have a clear idea how ambitious or talented she is. She was 'famously gifted'; she carried a battle-wand; she chose to be a scholar (ie, she knew the value of information); she got herself elected or appointed to the highest office. And when a magical threat entered her domain, the trailers seem to show that she chose to take it down.

The comparison I was making was 'ambitious, powerful, incredibly intelligent, manipulative, and knows it'. I wasn't claiming they were identical; but I think the comparison is very close.

hS

Reply Return to messages