Subject: Things I flagged
Author:
Posted on: 2016-06-28 16:09:00 UTC
-The Irish will no doubt be up in arms about their sacred figure (the Morrigan) being reimagined as an Animagus. Right?
-Har har, 'A Liar's Story'. There's a joke most of America has the wrong accent to get.
-Ilvermorny was half-founded by a Muggle! It was also founded in explicit imitation of Hogwarts, neatly explaining the four houses.
-The houses themselves... this is a really important point: they're not named after magical species, as various people objected to last time. They're named after individual magical creatures. Horned Serpent is named for the individual who lives nearby; Pukwudgie is named for William. Thunderbird is named for (the?) Thunderbird, which nothing here says has to be a species - just like the Horned Serpent, it's referred to in the individual. We already know it's related to the phoenix - could it be an ancestor?
--Following from that, I'd love to know the story of Webster's Wampus. We had mentions of them watching Wampus cubs playing - did he have a pet? A friend?
--And what about Chadwick's encounter with the Thunderbird? I bet there's a story there.
-Ilvermorny was founded as a wandmaking school! The education side of things only came in as trade.
-The early students and teachers at Ilvermorny were in part Native American (Wampanoag, Narragansett). Nor were the students all children. And James was a teacher (and joint head), too - a Muggle! Yes, but remember, wandmaking school. He was a craftsman, not a wizard.
-JKR sketches excellent action sequences (the entirety of Update 5), but they give me very little to say, other than:
-Ilvermorny has Pukwudgie security. ^^
-It also has a really convoluted Sorting Ceremony, and I think I know why: the Rap. Wait, hang on a minute:
-The Rap was repealled in 1965. Victory! Anyway:
-Magic was strictly regulated outside Ilvermorny. It's quite likely most of the students had never seen any flashy magic at all prior to reaching the school. So yes, the first thing they're shown is moving, mind-reading statues - to make a big impression.
-President Pickles is Super Speshul. Oh dear. She's still a villain though.
-Wands are (or were) heavily controlled - but also 'state-funded' as it were. And the 'large hall' implies something much more dynamic than a fussy old man trying a few wands to see what works best for you. We know the school has a flair for the dramatic, after all.
-The Houses! Yep, they were houses after all (awww; but at least it makes sense, with the Fauxgwarts thing). And how well did I <a href="http://disc.yourwebapps.com/discussion.cgi?id=199610;article=296770;searchterm=pukwudgie">divine their themes?
--Horned Serpent: The Mind, tends towards scholars. I guessed Water and either Friendly or Smothering. That's a big fat zero. My 'dull' alternative pegged it as the Slytherin equivalent, which it... isn't. Ultimately, HS is basically 'Isolt wanted to be in Ravenclaw, so she made a copy of it'. The Horned Serpent is shown to be something of a mystic, so this kind of fits too.
--Wampus: The Body, tends towards warriors. I guessed stealth. Haha no. My dull version was equivalent to Gryffindor, which is close: it's half of Gryffindor. Actually, I think Wampus is what I had Thunderbird pegged as. The first view we have of Wampus(es) in the wild is of rough-and-tumble play, so this fits the creature.
--Pukwudgie: The Heart, tends towards healers. I went with the trickster idea, but I'm glad to be wrong - the idea of 'Pukwudgie with a heart of gold' is kind of appealing. It also makes an interesting comment on the Muggle founder of the school - his house is the heart and the healer. I like it.
--Thunderbird: The Soul, tends towards adventurers. That's a... strange combination. I think what she means here is idealists, or simply activists. Chadwick was 'intelligent and tempestuous', and the house is named after something approximating a force of nature. I would be willing to bet that it was Thunderbird graduates who brought down the Rap.
-And finally, the most important thing, from the trailer:
What does this say?
It shows up as the pages flick back, and seems almost to be a set of wand pictures? The second word could be 'Gormlaith', but her name was Gormlaith Gaunt, and her wand was Slytherin's. So what's the first word?
hS