Subject: I'm somewhat relieved.
Author:
Posted on: 2016-06-29 23:12:00 UTC

As you mention, the Houses being named for specific beings is a major step in the right direction. Still problematic, but somewhat less so. A friend of mine who's of Wampanoag descent pointed out that each being had a tie to the Wampanoag as well (that's whose territory the school is in, btw). It looks like JKR has tweaked it somewhat after the freak out by critics (that or the leaked info was even more premature than it should have been) - my friend also pointed out the school parallels the foundin of Dartmouth.

Now …in brief, the history of Dartmouth was "look how great we are! We're gonna teach young Indian men to be ministers! Only we'll rarely if ever actually grant them permission to teach, and never treat them as equals to their white peers, and hold them to higher standards while granting more scholarships to white students . . . " But at the same time, it was a heck of a lot more than almost any other university was willing to do. So I'm very, very interested to see where JKR goes with this magical parallel.

Reply Return to messages