Subject: Ehhh...
Author:
Posted on: 2018-08-03 09:11:00 UTC

Gonna be honest, it doesn't really feel like Edward has enough characterization. His favorite thing to do is merely teasing his sister? Then again, perhaps there's a ton of characterization hiding behind his secretiveness...

However, the biggest problem I have is with the Powers section. The "His favorite method of killing is Avada Kedavra" bit really rubs me the wrong way- mostly because it reeks of trivialization. The Killing Curse is one of the three Unforgivable Curses- it's not something to be wielded like a gun or a sword. Heck, the wiki itself says that just throwing out Unforgivable Curses like nothing without Serious Consequences coming your way is a serious charge, and when it's something that can be pinned as a serious charge against a Sue, you do not want your agents doing it. (Not to mention, Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children is not part of the Potterverse, and thus, Edward shouldn't be able to use Potterverse spells without a Muggle-use Wand, which don't tend to come pre-loaded with Unforgivable Curses.)

Reply Return to messages