Subject: o.o o.O OoO
Author:
Posted on: 2021-03-08 10:41:35 UTC

That... was... awesome. ^_^ And absolutely hilarious; I was grinning the whole way through.

I really love how you've characterised both the Brothers Finwe, even if that Nameless Stranger is a bit... familiar with the High King's heir. ^_~ And I love the idea of Fingolfin Holmes rooting out Melkor as the cause of the troubles.

My best guess is that Melkor would still escape south and meet with Ungoliant, and quite possibly still kill the Trees; but Finwe and Feanor would still be in Tirion, so the Silmarils and Finwe would be safe. Without that personal stake, the Noldor wouldn't rebel - they'd wait until the Valar could organise a proper response.

Except possibly Galadriel; she might run off on her own vengeance quest. She's like that.

As to names: 'Huinesoron' is (slightly dodgy) Quenya, not Sindarin (the e would be an ë if it were still the end of a word). Kaitlyn I think I've called Anairë before - it translates her real name - but, uh, that's also the name of Fingolfin's wife, so maybe not the best to use. ;) She uses Celebestel a lot, which is Sindarin, but in Quenya would be Telpestel/Tyelpestel (estel is the same in both languages; the y version is formal Quenya, but they generally used the Telerin form without it, see Telperion).

Amused though I am, there will still be vengeance wreaked; just give me time to find the right way to do it... >:D

hS

PS: 'Zingenmir'... that would be Líralwë (literally 'We are singing') or Lirilwë ('we sing'), but it might be funnier to use the word for 'singer': Linda. ~hS

Reply Return to messages