Subject: Wow, how many times have I had that conversation? {X D
Author:
Posted on: 2013-09-10 03:47:00 UTC
This definitely sounds like a real conversation between a pro-Tolkien and "meh"-Tolkien person. I've heard just about all of these points from real people, and I think you've got a fair representation of both sides here—except that I'd personally be a whole lot more insistent than Sebak was about how freaking beautiful Tolkien's language is and nobody appreciates a well-turned sentence these days. >.>
Ahem. Anyway. As a piece of dialogue, this works pretty well. You've set the scene well enough that I know what the conversation is about and why it's happening. It helps that I already know who these characters are, and I'm not sure if it would be as enjoyable to someone who hasn't met them yet, but for the purpose of illustrating how some people really like Tolkien while others are indifferent, I think it's not terribly important.
There was one hitch for me:
"Fascinating, I know," Tish said, sighing. "Could you not be stereotypical? Anyhow, I read them for you. Happy? Right, stupid question," she added as Sebak arched an eyebrow.
At the end of this line, you've got events happening out of order: Tish responds to Sebak raising his eyebrow before he's shown to do it. Worse, the word "as" means that she reacts to his action at the same time he performs it.* When the reader inevitably realizes that the eyebrow must have happened first and Tish's reaction comes second, they have to pause and reset their mental image, which is a distraction. A small one, yes, but still something to be avoided. I'd rewrite the line like this:
"Fascinating, I know," Tish said, sighing. "Could you not be stereotypical? Anyhow, I read them for you. Happy?"
Sebak arched an eyebrow.
"Right, stupid question," she added.
This way, everyone is reacting to what came before in a linear progression of cause and effect. It is, you might say, logical. {= )
~Neshomeh
* Full disclosure: I was scarred for life by this fic and learned to hate the word "as" with a fiery burning passion. I take a pretty firm stance on when it should and shouldn't be used. Looser stances may technically be acceptable. Now, if you'll please pardon me, I have to go wipe some bloody sputum off my chin...