Subject: Meanwhile, I completely agree with Tish.
Author:
Posted on: 2013-09-10 21:32:00 UTC

Not to go on to much of a tangent, but I truly find LoTR to be really good, but not fantastic. The kea problem for me is that I am not a wordsmith, but a storyteller. When I read a story, I expect flow in narrative, and the actions motivating the story. I have read books that others have blasted as horribly written, but enjoyed them, as I found value in the story that was being told. One of my good friends, however, was a wordsmith. He could write the most beautiful prose, with description that could blow you away. However, I was a constant critic of his stories, because like Tolkien, he let the construction of the words and the description the the world take precedence over the characters and story. The number of arguments we have had over literature... So yeah, I'm with Tish here. Perhaps after I have finally finished the series I will write a paper on what, exactly, I find wrong with Mr. Tolkien's writing style.

As for the story you wrote Hermione, I found nothing wrong with it that Nesh has not already pointed out. I have not read anything with these two before, but what I gleamed about them is very interesting. Fascinating, you might say. I am very interested in seeing more from these two. Well done.

Reply Return to messages