Subject: Concrit!
Author:
Posted on: 2013-09-09 15:01:00 UTC

I actually have a slight problem with your opening line. It switches between a POV inside and outside the RC. I'll try and clarify that by bolding the stuff that feels like we're inside, and italicising what feels like we're outside:

There was a very hesitant knock at the door to RC #583. No sound came from within, but the door opened anyway, revealing a darkened room lit only by a projection lamp that was currently displaying a pattern of stars. The person who had been knocking entered...

'We' don't know who's knocking, suggesting we're on the other side of the door to them. Then we're outside, listening to 'no sound'. Then the door opens, presumably by way of the unseen knocker. Then we, from outside, see the room for the first time. Then, inside, we see the knocker come in...

But, that said, I can find nothing to complain about in the rest of the story (except the capital W in '... What is it?'). You do a good job of conveying the shifts in mood as the story progresses, and (in contrast to my last entry!) keep your characters physically present, rather than turning them into talking heads. And the pendant sounds quite pretty - is that truesilver as in mithril, or some other metal by the same name?

Oh, actually, one more thing! Lyra is a 'young woman' when she comes in, but halfway down she's a 'small girl'. Yes, technically that second description is accurate - but it feels like 'child', not 'tiny'. In this context, either 'petite' or simply 'short' might work better. Or, if she is as young as it implies, turn her into a 'young' or 'teenaged' girl at her introduction.

hS

Reply Return to messages