Subject: Draft, Part #2
Author:
Posted on: 2010-01-13 10:22:00 UTC

=====How soundproof is an RC?=====
Interesting question. Console BEEP!s have certainly been audible from beyond the doors on at least one occasion, but loud music in one room bothering someone trying to sleep in another doesn’t tend to be much of an issue. HQ is weird. You could probably get away with anything, including having your agents soundproof the place if they wish, though the Laws of Narrative Comedy may choose to override that. Specifics like these are not often nailed down.

====What Kind Of Things Can I PPC?====
As we all know, there’s a lot of badfic out there; far, far more than can be dealt with. The up side of this is that we can all pick and choose our missions, although our agents have to deal with whatever we (or the Flowers, convenient scapegoats that they are) choose to throw at them. However, there are a few limits.

Basically, any original work published and accessible by the public, whether on film, in text, on radio, or whatever, is a published canon. Parodies also count, even though they work somewhat differently. No published canon can be PPCd – we protect the plot continuum, regardless of our own opinions of the story. Therefore, despite the fact that stories such as [[Twilight]] and the [[The Inheritance Cycle]] are reviled by many PPCers, we cannot send our agents into the canon stories, only the badfics written for them. Thankfully, no one has to take missions for a fandom they don’t like.

=====What about adaptations or expanded or alternate works someone other than the author made? They’re not “original” published works.=====
No, but they’re still published, and therefore can have a fanfiction following of their own. For instance, the recent film adaptations of Lord of the Rings made several major changes from the original book, enough so that a fanfic based on those versions (called the [[movieverse]] around here) would be noticeably different from one based on the [[bookverse]]. It’s still an established canon.

As a side note, the line between various versions of a canon is a question up for debate. For example, the musical Wicked was adapted from a book of the same name, which was in turn partly based on L Frank Baum’s original Oz book series and partly on the 1939 film adaptation starring Judy Garland. These four versions all have many major overlapping elements, but also many conflicting disctinctions. When PPCing a story with multiple possible verses, an agent must bear in mind that just because the badfic author didn’t use the version of canon they prefer does not constitute a charge. If it’s canonical somewhere, it’s allowed.

The same applies for alternate works such as Lost in Austen, a recent television series depicting a Modern Girl who lands in (and messes up) Pride & Prejudice – which is legally allowed, as Austen’s work is old enough to be out of copyright. As much as most PPCers hate this (and we do hate it; you can see our outraged reactions on [http://disc.yourwebapps.com/discussion.cgi?disc=241484;article=568;title=PPC%20Message%20Board;pagemark=50 this thread]), there’s nothing we can do about it.

=====Are we allowed to PPC original badfic? That’s not published.=====
Sorry, no. In that case, the badfic is the Plot Continuum.

=====What fandoms does the PPC cover? If you guys hate Twilight and Eragon so much, are we not allowed to PPC badfic for them?=====
The PPC covers any fandom that needs it. We have specific dicisions for Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter just because there’s so much of it that some agents specialise in that canon only, but there are many, many more fandoms being dealt with. On the other hand, there are some lucky fandoms out there that have virtually no badfic – but we won’t mention which, or the Ironic Over-Power might just go about changing that.

You are, of course, allowed to PPC for Twilight and the Inheritance Cycle if you want. We don’t want you to feel like you can’t, or that you’ll be looked down on for it. It is commonly said that many agents aren’t sent into such canons because they can’t be trusted not to kill the canon characters, but if your agents happen to like it, go ahead! Really, go ahead. We encourage it.

=====How many chapters should a fic have in order to be PPCd?=====
Length of a fic has nothing to do with its quality; if it’s bad, it’s bad, and that can be illustrated in five thousand words or in fifty. While we’re on the subject, you don’t have to make missions a particular length; we encourage you to make it long enough to be worthwhile and illustrate both your characters and the fic’s awfulness a bit, but a novel-length epic for every badfic isn’t much fun, either. Play it by ear and just write what feels necessary. (Also, see below for some related points.)

=====I confess, I once wrote a badfic. It’s really awful. Can I PPC that?=====
Yes. It’s been done before, and there are probably very few PPCers who don’t have at least one such skeleton in their closests, so don’t feel bad about it, either. That you can look back now and recognise your mistakes – with good humour, no less! – is laudible. This is also particularly fun thing to do if one of your agents is a direct avatar of yourself, and remembers having written the fic before being recruited.

=====Can I PPC AUs, given that they’re not meant to be the same as canon?=====
Yes. Bad writing is bad writing, and being an alternate universe doesn’t (automatically) excuse out-of-character behaviour.

=====What about oddly formatted stories, like first person or epistolary works?=====
Yes, they’re fine, though you may need (or want) to deal with the odd style within your mission.

For first- and second- person fics, the [[Department of Sufficiently Advanced Technology]] has created a hand little device known as a [[crash dummy]], which acts as a stand-in for the author spirit, allowing agents to walk around as normal without having the authorial influence forced upon them. Written formats such as diaries can be dealt with in whatever way is most suitable for your mission; have the agents spend the entire time reading the text, if you want, but that’s a bit dull. Remember, the aim is to be entertainings, so if you can make a funny situation out of it, do so. If we don’t have a useful method for handling your particular badfic, make one up.

=====I’ve found a badfic that’s almost entirely made up of original characters, descendants of canon characters. Do I leave that alone?=====
It’s still a canon world, so you can charge for anything that breaks the laws of the canon. Good OCs exist, of course, and for your sake I hope these qualify, but if they claim to be descendants of a canon character who most definitely had no children, then it’s a charge, albeit not necessarily a big one. If it’s obviously a bad story, and you can name reasons why, then you can PPC it. If not, maybe you should leave it alone and find something worse to deal with.

=====The badfic I want to spork isn’t finished. What do I do?=====
There are a lot of unfinished fics around, some still being written, some abandoned. You can still PPC it. If the author writes more afterwards, you can PPC later chapters individually (Trojie and Pads did this several times with the [[Legendary Badfic]] [[Land Before Time: Littlefoot x Cera]]), or just ignore it – if it wouldn’t be funny to keep going, ignore it.

Just know that you cannot charge for something that hasn’t actually happened in a badfic, even if it’s obvious that it was going to.

=====What if the author took the badfic down before I finished my mission?=====
Then you have a choice; you can either scrap the mission, finish it anyway and post a note about how it’s been removed, or do what Jay and Acacia did in the Original Series and make a little drama about them having to rush out before they were deleted along with the fic.

As a matter of courtesy, if the author took down their work because they realised how bad it was, it’s generally considered poor form to spork it anyway.

=====Do I tell the badfic author that I’m PPCing their fic? Aren’t they supposed to take down the story or something?=====
NO.

For all the fun we have, we don’t actually police the fandom, and we cannot tell people what to do. Most of these badfics are sporked without the original author ever knowing about it, and generally, it’s better that they don’t. We don’t want to start a flame war, and why hurt their feelings if we don’t have to? Showing someone that their work has been mocked so thoroughly rarely results in a positive reaction. Some PPCers do choose to politely inform the badfic author, particularly if they know the person would have a laugh rather than burst into tears, but most don’t.

Also, you never tell an author to stop writing, or take down their stories; all we do is give them constructively critical feedback. We try to be nice people, see.

=====Wow, you’re picky. Anything else I shouldn’t pick for a PPC mission?====
Just that not every badfic is worth the time it takes to spork. Stop and ask yourself, what’s the point of sporking this fic? Yes, there are crimes against canon, but does that make it a story anyone will want to read?

Of course, going out and picking the most dramatically horrible fics you can find might not be good for your agent’s sanity, either. Or your own. And too many terrible fics can become monotonous after a while.

(Yes, I suppose this is getting rather picky, but at the end of the day, it’s still your choice, and we’re just giving advice.)


For a list of perfectly sporkable works, check out the [[Unclaimed Badfic]] page.

Reply Return to messages