Subject: I'm really fee- sorry.
Author:
Posted on: 2015-06-02 00:17:00 UTC
This was really good!
Subject: I'm really fee- sorry.
Author:
Posted on: 2015-06-02 00:17:00 UTC
This was really good!
Before you ask: This is going to be a relatively minor RC, and I don't want to detract from the major three that I'm currently rotating around. There is a damn good reason for bringing in (hopefully) the last two agents I'll be introducing, and that's gonna tie into the big thing I'm planning for my Floaters' team in the future. (Though it won't be anytime soon, alas, since I'll be extremely busy in the coming weeks and months. I'll most likely get to it in the autumn term, once I get a stable income!)
Anyway, without further ado, please give a warm welcome to Agent Backslash and his mentor Whitney, from RC #88224646BA of the DMS-VG division! Join them as they take on a bloodthirsty replacement of a certain green-clad, Koopa-stomping plumber in...
"The Green Maul"
Bonus: Alternate Ending
Eh, I'll update the wiki tomorrow.
The mission reads quite a bit better than when I was betaing it. But it seems that a few errors slipped through the cracks. HG and EPL already caught the missing W in "wall," so here's the rest:
the Dedede dummy which had surreptitiously taken the canon’s place prepared to fight.
That should be "the Dedede dummy that had surreptitiously taken the canon's place"
“Wow, poor Luigi,” Honedge!Shulk said sympathetically. “Looks like that advice wasn’t enough to help him.”
“Why do you think that?”
“Oh, I don’t know. I simply made an… educated guess.”
Beat. “…It’s the ‘Green Mario’ thing, I’m guessing,” Whitney said finally.
The Shulk double nodded slowly. “Correct. Though he’s technically been a semi-clone since his debut.”
Apparently everyone else got what you're saying here, but could you please explain what you are referencing?
Once they had made sure that Not!Luigi was well and truly gone, they returned to their RC, Honedge!Shulk sat down at the foot of the single bed once again.
This is a comma splice. Either add an "and" before "Honedge!Shulk" or split the two sentences.
And I have to echo Tira here: You could have folded the "alternate" ending into the mission proper. Whay did you decide to split them?
Luigi is constantly treated in the fandom as an inferior clone of Mario, which may have stemmed from the fact that he started out as a palette swap of him during their 8-bit days. The semi-clone thing is from Smash, though, and I just fixed that to make it more specific.
I was erring on the side of caution when I cut out the alternate ending, because I'm still not sure how well people would take the agents actually visiting the canons in their element. Even if I personally think it would be funny to have the real Luigi remain completely oblivious to the whole mess, agents' interactions with canons should in general be kept to a safe minimum. If people want the bonus ending to be included in the actual mission, though, I guess I'd be happy to oblige!
Also, because I have nowhere else to put this, paging... basically everyone working on the Rose Potter cleanup interlude. I may or may not get to work on a little something today that you may all be interested in...
I liked most of this, but there are two things that rubbed me the wrong way.
[...] the anthropomorphic Honedge was so engrossed in this and many other questions that he didn’t realize that he’d passed by the RC he was looking for until he’d kept walking for several minutes.
This is not how PPC HQ usually works. If you don’t pay attention, you should soon arrive where you should be, although that’s not always where you intended to go. Realizing that you’ve walked too far and trying to return should actually make it more difficult to get there, until you are distracted again. Since Flashback absentmindedly walked past the door rather than crashing into it, he apparently was not supposed to be there yet, possibly because the narrative laws of comedy required that he arrived only after Whitney got the mission, they would have no time to talk, and would go into the fic mostly unprepared. I was disappointed when this didn’t happen.
It had taken quite a bit of convincing to get Dedede to head through the portal to where Ike was, but the hammer-wielding bird had finally relented once Whitney told him that the match had been cancelled. He wouldn’t be fighting Luigi today – but there was a free-for-all open on the Gaur Plain stage, with Ike already getting ready to go.
Why didn’t we see this? It’s true that interacting too much with canons is frowned upon, but doing it off-page doesn’t help your cause, especially when you rant about "Show, Don’t Tell" in your author’s notes.
Typos:
She looked at him with frightened apprehension, but he turned to he and added [...]
The second "he" should be "her".
The humanized Sword Pokémon slammed into the opposite all, and before he could raise his Monado to defend himself, Not!Luigi had begun pummeling him, kicking and pounding.
Oh, eatpraylove already noticed the missing "w", and I don’t agree with her second point. Not!Luigi had already begun pummeling Backslash (past perfect) before Backslash could raise his weapon (past tense) looks perfectly right to me.
HG
I totally forgot that about the PPC HQ. Stupid me. And I changed things up so that we actually get to see Whitney relocating Dedede, so yeah.
And one thing I should clarify... Backslash wasn't told about the agent protocol before stepping into the mission, which is why he acted out of haste and ended up getting the snot beaten out of him. So he actually WAS unprepared, mentally at least, and as eatpraylove pointed out, he was also a little 'enthusiastic' about the job - a combination which can be incredibly risky knowing how PPC missions usually go.
Thanks for defending Luigi's honor. I like him better than Mario anyway. Whitney and Backslash balance each other out pretty well, but I'm confused about a few aspects of all this.
For starters, what the heck is Backslash's species? I know he's a former Stu and therefore a bit canon-breaking by default, but having him as both a Honedge gijinka and a Shulk replacement strikes me as a little overpowered. And mostly confusing. (I assume you wrote the snippet of fic he came from?) He also strikes me as a little too violent for active duty, even with the Glitter removal and therapy sessions.
I feel like you brought up the possibility of a Wii Fit Trainer Agent in a thread some time ago; if you did, props for somehow making it work. (Still waiting for Brenda and/or Vampire!Robin to get more screentime...)
My usual list of things...
-"...I thought it was the Villager who was portrayed as a psychopathic mass-murderer by the fandom, and not [– OW!]"
This doesn't feel natural. Try something like "...Usually the Villager gets the psycho mass-murderer treatment in this fandom, not [– OW!]"
Nice trick with using the dummy to protect a threatened/Stufluenced canon. (Ike was under a little Stufluence, right?)
-"...rubbing his gloved hand over his nose and noting that it was a decal on skin as smooth as glass."
Also clunky. If the point is to show Backslash's surprise at the (ingenious!) Mii Fighter disguise, try something like "'What am I now?' he asked. He ran a gloved hand over his face, then pulled it back when he realized that his skin had the texture of plate glass. Furthermore, his features felt like decals of some kind."
-"...He may need a monster to clobber that there Kirby, but he wouldn’t act that cruel by any stretch of the imagination."
Why does a character ostensibly from Smash Bros. know a meme relating to the Kirby dub?
More tomorrow, when I'm not sleepy.
Like Tira said, your writing still suffers from what the pony fandom calls "Lavender unicorn syndrome." It's OK to refer to your characters by name most of the time and by the appropriate pronoun most other times.
-"...Not!Luigi apparently had the Scrappy ability, allowing his Fighting-type moves to hit Ghost-types;..."
Um...no. If he's in the Smash Bros. verse, Backslash should be dealing with the Not!Luigi fight as a Shulk clone, not as a Honedge gijinka. Same goes for the realization about No Guard and Green Missile equating to a Body Slam (by the way, it's much closer to a Skull Bash or Headbutt).
-"The humanized Sword Pokémon slammed into the opposite all, and before he could raise his Monado to defend himself, Not!Luigi had begun pummeling him..."
One, opposite wall. Two, "Not!Luigi began pummeling him...". Three, Backslash has a name (of sorts), so please use it.
-"“Why not just use Amiibos? Surely they’d be harder to distinguish from the actual canons, if only we could get them to work like they do in the games.”"
I like your thinking! Good luck getting them to the PPC, though; amiibo (note the lowercase a) are in pretty high demand throughout World One, as far as I know. Also, given what the crash dummies go through, your solution might be a little too expensive for comfort.
Heh-heh, maybe I should've taken you up on beta-reading this after all. XD Seriously, thank you for doing this mission, and I look forward to your master plan for Falchion and co.
First off, I am so sorry that I couldn't get to this and the other concrit responses sooner, as I was working with my family on a yard project and couldn't come online. Anyway, I'll try to be quick with answering your questions before I dash off to campus...
To paraphrase the Wiki, Backslash was an AU version of Shulk as an anthropomorphic Pokemon (and yes, I made up the snippet from his homefic), so he's technically a Honedge gijinka with Shulk's appearance, and therefore wouldn't be any more OP than Falchion would be. One thing I should've noted sooner was that Backslash does not use the actual Monado Arts or Xenoblade attacking moves, but the closest analogs from the Pokemon moves. He can also use only four moves on any occasion: Pursuit, Aerial Ace, Shadow Sneak, and one of his status moves at a time. (And yes, I'm aware of how aggressive he is - He's gonna be toned down via character development in future missions).
Fixed, and fixed. The reason he knows of the Kirby dub? FicPsych. XD I did say he spent a few days there, didn't I?
Good point. I changed it up to say, "Smash Bros. doesn't take type effectiveness or abilities into account" or whatever. Also fixed. And yeah, I should've known that amiibos are crazy rare, so that's changed too.
Thank you for your feedback and concrit, all in all. And you are more than welcome to beta-read the next mission I have for these two! :)
Good job on the mission! I have to confess, Whitney reminds me a lot of this Rhymes With Witch strip. (Warnings for gore.)
I really like the vibe that Whitney and Backslash have going as a team. The main issue I had with the mission is that you tend to use overly long epithets for the characters. "The Sword Pokémon-slash-Homs" is a particularly notable one, as you use it multiple times. I know it's a little harder with Backslash, since he doesn't think of himself by that name, but it's a trend that occurs in all your missions, not just this one. Don't be afraid to repeat character names or use pronouns. (Confession - this is the reason I made a pair of agents of different genders, so that it'd be easier to keep track of who's who.) Also, I think you could have incorporated the "Alternate Ending" into the main fic, but that's just me being pedantic.
Overall, I really enjoyed this mission! Maybe I just have weird taste, but it's probably my favorite of your missions.
Thank you for the kind words :) I honestly wasn't expecting that much from this mission because this means I now have like what, four RCs now? XD Anyway, Whitney's "action girl" shtick was based on the WFT's Memetic Badass treatment by the fandom in general, but she certainly won't go as overboard as in that comic - like E.V.L., she always goes for the quickest, most efficient means of assassination. Even then she trumps Glitter Girl in that department a bit because she doesn't like using weapons unless required and unless she can bring her Header into play, she often has to rely on her bare hands alone. I'll try to give just as many kills to Backslash, though, and put Whitney in tight spots as often as her partner, so she doesn't look TOO good.
Glad you liked the mission - these two will be back soon, and I'll keep your style advice in mind! I'll have to find another fic for them, though, and aside from IRL stuff I have my main RCs to focus on first as well. My horse and his demon in particular have quite a backlog to sort out... starting with the cleanup job in the wake of a certain Legendary Badfic...
This was really good!
OrangeYpshi99, OtangeYoshi99, OrangeyOshhi99, and OramgeYoshi99. So no, four.