Subject: ... so they're the Jedi Order, then?
Author:
Posted on: 2016-03-11 16:11:00 UTC

Seriously, except for the mindwiping, this is exactly what the Jedi did under the Old Republic: abduct magical children to raise in their proper environment.

I think one thing you've missed is that the pureblood exodus happened a hundred years before Rappaport Segregation was introduced. That's a lot of time for Muggleborn kids to start a couple of generations of their own families - and for whatever the term is for non-pure-non-immediately-muggleborn families to expand.

In fact, let's run some numbers. Hogwarts has around 1000 students, indicating that every year (of seven) there are roughly 150 magical children born in Britain. That's out of a total of around 500,000 live births. If we ignore for the moment the post-breeding-age witches and wizards, that suggests that around 1/3000 people in Britain are wizards, or around 20,000.

So. North America in the 1690s had a non-Native population of 200,000 or so. Assuming we're looking at the same proportions, that comes out as...

... uh...

... nearly 70 witches and wizards in colonial America at the time of the Pureblood exodus and the Salem witch trials.

... I think JKR may not be very good with numbers.

hS

(Is Ilvermorny under MACUSA laws? Not sure what you're thinking of, here.)

Reply Return to messages