Subject: Your challenge, should you choose to accept it: Rewrite a scene!
Author:
Posted on: 2020-02-16 20:36:57 UTC

I recently got it into my head to look at an old piece of HP fanfic featuring one of my characters, Jenni. Seeing as the piece in question is over ten years old, my response can be predictably summed up as "wow, this is terrible!"

So I decided to rewrite it. I wanted to see what I would do differently after so long, and I had some new ideas about Jenni that I wanted to develop further, and while I was at it, I wanted to update the story to be as compliant as possible with current canon. It was a lot of fun! I've put the final result up on AO3 and on Fanfiction.net, where you can also find the original version of the piece for comparison, if you're curious.

Now, I invite all of you to try something similar! Take an old piece of writing (original, fanfic, PPC, whatever) and do it over, keeping what you like about it and using what you've learned since you wrote it to make it better. Your "old" doesn't have to be ten years old, just old enough that it makes you cringe. ^_~ I also suggest that it shouldn't be too long. The piece I started from was about 1,000 words and the rewrite ended up being about 5,000. Though, the opposite could also happen! Editing can be about cutting out what's not necessary as much as or more than about adding what is.

I anticipate that the amount of time this will take will vary widely, so I don't want to put a hard deadline on the challenge, but if you want a goal to shoot for, let's say it ends when this post gets to the bottom of the Board. Then we can always restart it if people are still working. If you're going to participate, go ahead and let me know here, so I can keep track.

If you finish in the meantime, great! Post a reply here with links to the new story and the old story, and hopefully get some feedback. I've been a bit scarce around here lately, but I'll make an effort to respond, since I'm starting this thing.

I chose not to use a beta since I didn't for the original and I wanted the raw result, but definitely do if you want to.

Most importantly, have fun! Don't stress about being perfect, or as good as anyone else. This is about seeing your own personal improvement, which will look different for all of us. {= )

~Neshomeh

Reply Return to messages