Subject: Re: prompt
Author:
Posted on: 2018-01-01 12:43:00 UTC

This is a very different story from anything else I've read, and it made for a very interesting read. You've really done an incredible job of seeding this narrative with little bits and pieces of world-building detail, but only enough to inform the reader that we aren't looking at humans in an Earth setting. You don't slow the action or dialogue down with excess details like the descriptions of the characters or the society they live in or the magic system that (maybe?) exists. With all those questions essentially forced under the rug, it leads the reader to focus more on the parts of the story that really matter: the relationships between the characters and their emotions—in other words, how human they are. Reading a story this way was a very unique experience, and it made the ending hit even harder.

One little nitpick, regarding this pair of paragraphs:

"'Dantril’s brought in someone new. We’ll see, Lath,' she said. 'We’ll see.'

'I know you want me to have all the answers, but I don’t,' she said, when he didn’t respond. 'I wish I knew, too. But we can’t, Lath. We aren’t gods.'"

I suggest moving the "when he didn't respond" to the front of that second paragraph, as the start of a new paragraph and new quotation mark tricked my brain into thinking Lath was speaking it.

—doctorlit, sleepy, but still getting through these reviews

Reply Return to messages